Michael SatterfieldThe owner of Wetherall Restoration in Longmont Colorado has been indicted by a grand jury on January 27th, 2020, on five counts of theft, as well as tax evasion and failure to file tax returns, according to a report from the Daily Camera. Police say Frederick Spencer Wetherall collected nearly $1 million dollars from customers who found him mostly via eBay, hoping to buy clones of the classic 1969 Chevrolet Camaro ZL-1.
According to the indictment from the Colorado Attorney General’s Office, Wetherall would advertise his services on eBay and have customers pay cash up-front and sign a contract outlining the specifications of their customized Camaro, but the contracts usually lacked an expected completion date. From 2013-2019 Weather collected almost $1 million dollars, without ever delivering a vehicle or refunding customers in full when they canceled their orders. Police say that Wetherall used photos of different Camaros to show customers’ progress on their project car but would blame the delays on paint and bodywork being performed by another shop.
 |
| image via IMDB |
Looking at his eBay history (username Bear123jetski), the account has some fairly mixed reviews, while it seems most customers were happy with their parts and car purchases, others have complaints ranging from undisclosed rusty frames to missing titles. But the feedback might be misleading as it appears that many customers would end up striking deals offline after finding Wetherall’s listing on eBay. Some of those offline buying experiences have been shared on the consumer complaint site Ripoff Report.
The stories mirror what is in the indictment, one report from 2015 a buyer claims that he found Wetherall on eBay and arranged to purchase a ZL1 Camaro clone, they agreed on a price and a 10-month timeline only to have the process drag on four years. This customer eventually did get their car, but the user goes on to claim that once it arrived the car had a litany of issues including a leaking water pump, poor craftsmanship, and mismatched parts.
 |
| image via IMDB |
Another story from a buyer in Louisiana describes an eBay auction where Wetherall reached out before the auction closed to strike a deal but “the transaction would have to be offline from e-bay and my bank would need to send his bank, a wire transfer.” From there the buyer claims that the car was not numbers matching as advertised, that Wetherall didn’t have a title as promised, and the car had undisclosed damage. The complaints on Ripoff Report stretch back to 2012 and all described similar stories. The buyer in Louisiana’s story was also posted to the website Scamion, followed by a number of complaints of the same nature ranging from 2015-2019. In this thread, it appears that Wetherall decided to defend himself in a reply that doxes the customer by publishing his home address after encouraging people to look at the car themselves.
In a self-published post on Medium.com from August 2019, Wetherall describes himself: “Spencer Wetherall is an award-winning classic car restoration specialist. In fact, he is the only classic Camaro ZL-1 expert in the world. In addition to running his business, Wetherall Restorations, He also owns, writes, and directs Time Machine Camaros, a TV show about classic car restoration, and ” he has rebuilt over a hundred custom cars for clients from all around the world.” The same text can be found on his weebly.com site.
Wetherall was released on a $15,000 bond and is set to appear in court on February 3rd, 2020.
Collecting nearly $1 million without delivering a single car is astonishing. How did this go unnoticed for so long?
I’m one of the victims he was juggling the photos of all different cars and sending them to all the customers. I flew out there twice to see my car. Even though he scammed all the people that Attorney General‘s office screwed it all up and took care of him because he’s friends with Robert Redford. I was told two times by the senior assistant Attorney General that I will get my money back plus interest. He did 90 days in jail. We each got back $5000 and I get a check each one for 34 hours so I tell 300 years old I’ll get my $65,000 back. There’s so much missing in the story and it should be told. He was making cars and he was selling them for $65,000 to a hot rod shop in Texas who was selling them for 75,000 and I gave the proof and the information to the Attorney General‘s office and they did nothing with it. So he was getting paid by us to build a car that he was selling and making his money. The legal system is a real joke.