Where Cars Meet Culture
Jan 13, 2025
Subscribe Button

Why Do Men Pay More For Car Insurance?

4 years ago
4 mins read

Why Do Men Pay More For Car Insurance?

TGR Staff

If you’ve wondered why your wife or girlfriend is paying less car insurance despite both of you being around the same age, in the same location, and driving similar cars, there’s a good reason. Well, a few reasons, actually.


5 Reasons Men Pay More For Car
Insurance.

For years, men have paid higher insurance
rates. It’s not because insurance companies are being unfair. It’s about how
they view risk. Here’s why men, especially, young men below the age of 30, pay
more for car insurance.


Men tend to
be riskier drivers:

Young men under 25 pay the highest auto
insurance rates because they are perceived as a higher risk. Male drivers age 16 to 19 have a
four times higher risk of crashes than for older drivers.

In this age group, men are more likely to
speed, not buckle up and engage in reckless driving behavior than women of the
same age. This
results in more car crashes. According to the
Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), 71% of
all motor vehicle crash deaths in 2018 involved males.

Moreover, a lot of these crashes tend to be fatal and result in either severe injuries or death. If you speak to any wrongful death attorney in the country, they’ll testify that a lot of their cases involve male drivers. The added risk of male drivers means insurance premiums have to be higher so insurance companies can cover their backs. 


We like to show off our car’s
performance:

Men are naturally more competitive than women.
Younger men, in particular, want to impress their friends with their driving
skills and their car’s performance. That often means a heavier foot on the gas
pedal, sharp cornering, and modifying our cars to make them more powerful.

Young men also tend to have more passengers in
the car. With more passengers, comes more distractions and reckless behavior,
especially if egged on by their friends to drive faster or perform stunts. This
adds up to a higher risk for insurance companies.

Why Do Men Pay More For Car Insurance?


We are more likely to buy faster
cars:

One study showed that 100% of Dodge Viper buyers were male. Males
also dominated other sports car brands — 94% of Corvette, 
91% of Nissan GT-R, and 89% of Porsche 911 buyers were male.

No matter the age, most men can’t help loving
fast cars. It’s in our blood, literally. ScienceABC
says it’s linked to testosterone. When we get into a sports car and hare down
the road at lightning speed, our testosterone levels spike. Along with that
comes a rise in adrenalin and dopamine (that feel-good chemical in the brain).

Seeking a dopamine rush is addictive and can
perpetuate the need for speed. That’s why we’re more inclined to buy sports
cars, which attracts higher insurance rates.


We rack up more traffic violations
than women:

At
age 40, it seems the tables turn and
women end up paying
more for car insurance
. However, men at all ages, continue to have more car accidents and pick
up more traffic violations and DUIs. In 2010, four out of five DUI violations
were attributed to male drivers. While DUIs among the female population is on
the increase, men still receive more DUIs than women.

More
car accidents and traffic violations lead to more insurance claims and
subsequent rate increases. So, thanks to more traffic violations, most men may
still end up paying more than women for car insurance.


Men drive more miles than women

Men spend 19% more time behind the wheel and drive 27% more miles than women. For insurance
companies, more time on the road means a higher chance of car accidents. If
your circumstances change and you are driving fewer miles, let your insurance
company know. Some insurers are willing to adjust rates according to mileage.

Why Do Men Pay More For Car Insurance?


How Can Male Drivers Lower Their
Insurance Rate?

Insurance companies weigh up risk when determining
insurance rates. To gauge risk, they look at a number of factors, such as credit score,
driving history, marital status, location, type of vehicle, and claims history.

You can lower your risk by maintaining a clean
driving record, keeping a good credit score, installing an anti-theft device,
and inquiring about discounts. Many insurance companies offer the following
discounts:

    
Good student discount. If you’re a student and
you keep your grades up, it can help bring your car insurance rate down.

    
Multi-policy or multi-driver discounts. If you
hold more than one policy with your insurer or have a multi-driver plan, you
could qualify for lower rates.

    
Military discount. Some insurers offer
military personnel and veterans discounted rates.

    
Pay-in-full discount. Pay your entire year’s
premiums upfront and you could receive a discount of up to 10%.

In addition, if you get married, inform your
insurance company. Married people are seen as more responsible and, therefore,
enjoy lower rates. Even 25-year old males who are viewed as high risk, see
their rates drop after getting married.

So, gentlemen, despite women getting the rap
as bad drivers, it turns out insurance companies did their homework and
discovered that it is men, not women, who are the riskier drivers. The good
news is that as men get older and start families, they tend to become safer
drivers. And as your driving record improves, so too should your car insurance
rate.


Wrapping Up 

While it might not be much fun having to pay more for car insurance than women, it isn’t hard to see why. Insurance companies take everything into account to protect their investment essentially. So if men are riskier, it stands to reason that they pay more. 

But don’t take that as a reason to not get car insurance at all. It’s there for a reason, should the worst happen. Make sure that you still get it, even if you have to pay more. And make sure you know how to file an insurance claim. You never know when you might need it. 

So, gentlemen, despite women getting the rap as bad drivers, it turns out insurance companies did their homework and discovered that it is men, not women, who are the riskier drivers. The good news is that as men get older and start families, they tend to become safer drivers. And as your driving record improves, so too should your car insurance rate.

Michael Satterfield

Michael Satterfield is the founder of The Gentleman Racer, a leading automotive lifestyle site blending cars, travel, and culture. Known for its compelling storytelling and unique perspective, the site has become a go-to destination for car enthusiasts and style aficionados.

A Texan with a passion for classic cars and motorsports, Michael is also a hands-on restorer, currently working on a 1960s SCCA-spec Formula Super Vee and other project cars. As the head of the Satterfield Group, he consults on branding and marketing for top automotive and lifestyle brands, bringing his deep industry knowledge to every project.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Don't Miss

Why Driving A Paid-Off Car Is The New Status Symbol In 2025

In 2025, the concept of automotive prestige is shifting; during the pandemic,

U-Haul Now Has A Race Car Trailer

We have used a lot of U-Haul trailers over the years, moving